By Scott T. Allison and George R. Goethals
Most social scientists define heroism as exceptional pro-social behavior that is voluntary and involves risk and self-sacrifice. Although we respect that definition and recognize its value, we take a more subjective approach in defining a hero.
If you haven’t read our first heroes book, our definition of a hero is based on our research on people’s stated choices of heroes. We’ve asked many hundreds of people to tell us who their heroes are, and why. From our data it’s pretty clear that heroism is in the eye of the beholder. Preferences for heroes are as varied as people’s taste in music, movies, and paintings. Defining a hero is like defining a good meal at a restaurant. It depends on your values, your personal experiences, and maybe even the current developmental stage of your life.
Cancer victims name cancer survivors as their heroes. Soccer players list soccer stars as their heroes. In short, your needs and motives determine whom you choose as heroes. Maturity and development play a role in hero selection, with younger people tending to choose heroes known for their talents, physical skills, and celebrity status. Older people tend to favor moral heroes. As we get older and wiser, our tastes in heroes evolve. Some have suggested that with age and wisdom, our choice of heroes improves — perhaps as we get older we become more discriminating and more respectful of the term “hero”.
The point we wish to make is that every person we have profiled in this blog is someone’s hero. We didn’t choose the heroes whom we profile on this blog — you did. Each hero may not be your personal hero, but he or she is somebody’s hero, and the reasons are valid and meaningful to the person holding them.
Even Joseph Campbell, the great mythologist and founder of the study of heroes, acknowledged that heroism is in the eye of the beholder. Campbell said, “You could be a local god, but for the people whom that local god conquered, you could be the enemy. Whether you call someone a hero or a monster is all relative….” (The Power of Myth, p. 156).
The World War II German soldier who died, said Campbell, “is as much a hero as the American soldier who was sent over there to kill him.” Campbell believed that the moral objective of heroism “is that of saving a people, saving a person, or supporting an idea.”
Although we agree with Campbell, and others, that heroism is in the eye of the beholder, we will never profile people such as Adolf Hitler in our blog, even if Hitler is considered heroic to small segment of society. There are some people whose values are so repugnant to us, and to the reasonable majority, that we will never profile them here.
We’ve found that people’s beliefs about heroes tend to follow a systematic pattern. After polling a number of people, we discovered that heroes are perceived to be highly moral, highly competent, or both. More specifically, heroes are believed to possess eight traits, which we call The Great Eight. These traits are smart, strong, resilient, selfless, caring, charismatic, reliable, and inspiring. It’s unusual for a hero to possess all eight of these characteristics, but most heroes have a majority of them.
As authors of this blog, we do have our own personal heroes. Our heroes combine great selflessness with great ability. In our second heroes book we call heroes of this type Traditional Heroes. One of us (Scott Allison) identifies Roberto Clemente his greatest hero. Clemente was a great baseball player who died helping earthquake victims. The other of us (George Goethals) calls Abraham Lincoln his greatest hero. Lincoln showed remarkable heroic leadership while healing a divided nation and freeing slaves.
When we were younger, a person didn’t have to be particularly moral or selfless to be a hero to us. The person just had to be a star athlete or great rock star. We’ve outgrown this type of hero, which we call a Transitional Hero. Now our heroes have to accomplish far more than show great ability. They must also perform some exemplary action in the service of others.
Our research has also found that there are at least 12 functions of heroism. Heroes give us hope, heroes energize us, heroes develop us, heroes heal us, heroes impart wisdom, heroes are role models for morality, heroes offer safety and protection, heroes give us positive emotions, heroes give us meaning and purpose, heroes provide social connection and reduce loneliness, heroes help individuals achieve personal goals, and heroes help society achieve societal goals.
We will certainly continue to welcome any debates about the validity of our contentions in this blog. Critiques about the hero-worthiness of a particular individual may sharpen our thinking about who are the special men and women among us who deserve the term “hero” associated with their names. In the mean time, let’s honor the diversity of opinion out there about who our heroes are. We’re all in a different place in life, and our heroes shift and evolve as we ourselves shift and evolve.
And please, keep sending us your suggestions for heroes to profile. We love receiving your emails and welcome your input.
Allison, S. T. (Ed.) (2022). The 12 functions of heroes and heroism. Richmond: Palsgrove.
Allison, S. T., & Goethals, G. R. (2011). Heroes: What They Do & Why We Need Them. New York: Oxford University Press.
Allison, S. T., & Goethals, G. R. (2013). Heroic Leadership: An Influence Taxonomy of 100 Exceptional Individuals. New York: Routledge.
Campbell, J. (1988). The Power of Myth. (with Bill Moyers).
7 thoughts on “Our Definition of "Hero"”
Excellent explanation!!! Thank you for sharing that and it prompts me to get your book to read all about your perspective and research.
(PS: I still think that Bieber and Gaga and others don’t qualify but I guess they don’t stoop to the Hitler measure for disqualification!)
Thank you, Alice. Shame on us for not making our perspective clearer a long time ago. Better late than never, I suppose.
I have enjoyed this blog and your book. I am using the Great Eight in my seminars on writing novels.
And I think you have justified your hero-selections with the Great Eight. One author I read who identified a fictional hero from a fictional villain said they share all the same qualities but one. A hero will sacrifice himself for the good others whereas a villain sacrifices others for his own gain.
I wonder if your research shows a Great Eight to classify villains?
Greg, that’s very flattering to hear that you’re using our work on heroes to assist others in writing novels. Joseph Campbell’s analysis of heroes truly revolutionized how we view the heroic narrative.
In our research we did indeed uncover a Great Eight for villains, although we called it the Evil Eight. We mention these briefly in our chapter on evil in our book. Villains’ characteristics include Smart, Resilient, Violent, Greedy, Mentally Ill, Immoral, Egotistical, and Vengeful. So you correct in noting that there is some overlap between our conceptions of heroes and villains, along with notable differences, too.
A hero for one could be trash to another.I agree that it lies on the beholder and depends on his principles
That’s a good and reasonable definition of hero, Scotty and George. I like the controversial entries here, because they promote dialogue, exchange of ideas and values, and hopefully even some self examination. Challenging somebody’s opinion may not change their mind, but it will help them clarify their own thoughts about what they’ve taken for granted, which can only be good. I hope your brother decides to come here and join in.
It’s also interesting that some people think being over-inclusive dilutes the value of heroism. I prefer to think that there’s a hero in all of us and we’ll have reached a true high point of civilization when everybody is a hero.
Guys, your spotlight on our need for heroes is very insightful.
Heroes do frequently seem to be the embodiment of our own goals.
Growing up in the 40’s and 50’s during the heyday of the silver-screen cowboy, Tarzan, and Superman, I decided pretty early that I wanted to be the good guy saving the day. I’m thankful also to have had a heroic, hard-working Dad. Dad was a milkman who woke early to support my mother and my four brothers. I’ll never forget how his truck skidded one icy winter morning and Dad pushed his young assistant out the open cab to keep him from enduring the ensuing crash. Throughout his life, Dad had shards of glass continue to surface from the broken windshield.
To me, his concern for the boy who assisted him on the milk truck was much more heroic than any good deed performed by the TV or movie stars.
Comments are closed.