Arachnophonia: The Holy or the Broken

Editor’s note: Arachnophonia (“Arachno” = spider / “-phonia” = sound) is a regular feature on our blog where members of the UR community can share their thoughts about resources from the Parsons Music Library‘s collection.

All links included in these posts will take you to either the library catalog record for the item in question or to additional relevant information from around the web.

Today’s installment of Arachnophonia is by student manager Laeticia (class of 2026) and features a book examining the cultural significance of the Leonard Cohen song “Hallelujah”. Thanks, Laeticia!

The Holy or the Broken: Leonard Cohen, Jeff Buckley, and the Unlikely Ascent of “Hallelujah” by Alan Light

“Hallelujah” originates from the Hebrew verb hillel, which translates to “praise Jah(God).” It is a common term among those who grew up in faith, but many of us also relate it to the melodious and anthemic Leonard Cohen song. As a Christian myself, I’ve always cherished the anthemic beauty of the chorus that yielded such a strong spiritual significance, but Alan Light’s The Holy or the Broken has made me see the song in a new light.

Alan Light is a music journalist who has written for major publications like Rolling Stone and The New York Times. He authored several books on music and culture, however, he is most famous for his book The Holy or the Broken which explores the history and impact of Leonard Cohen’s song “Hallelujah”.

Contrary to popular belief, “Hallelujah” is not just about “someone who has seen the light” as the song quotes, but like most of Leonard Cohen’s songs it is a blend of sacred and sensual. The song combines the rollercoaster of emotions humans experience on a daily basis. From being something you “shout out on Sunday in a happy voice to something that happens in a way that is cold, broken, and lonely” says Alan Light.

In The Holy or the Broken Alan Light explores the varying interpretations of Leonard Cohen’s iconic song “Hallelujah,” revealing the depths and contradictions that make it resonate with so many. Light’s exploration opens up a rich tapestry of meanings that extend beyond faith, and provide personal, cultural, and historical contexts that show how “Hallelujah” has evolved in contemporary society — from a hymn of praise to a poignant commentary on love, loss, and longing.

This book not only challenges readers to reconsider their own interpretations but also highlights the song’s impact across diverse musical landscapes. It’s a compelling read for anyone looking to deepen their understanding of this modern classic.

Digital Resources: Rock’s Backpages

The Music Library has more resources available than physical items. We’re highlighting some of our digital resources, and including information about them as told by our student employees.

Today’s digital resource is:

Rock’s Backpages

Rock's Back Pages logo

Archive of rock and pop music journalism from mainstream publications and niche magazines.

Here is what student manager Cole (class of 2021) had to say about Rock’s Backpages:

Rock’s Backpages is an online archive of popular music journalism, from industry standards like Pitchfork and Rolling Stone, to more obscure and international publications, such as Stereo Review and Melbourne Weekly. Although the site catalogues a wide array of content (including reviews, letters, obituaries, book excerpts, press releases, columns, and more), the advanced search function makes it easy to filter by subject, author, original publication, and format.

My favorite use of the site is to read old reviews of albums and artists that I like, to get a sense of contemporary critical reception. In a 1980 review of U2’s debut album Boy, Paul Mory calls the group’s music “not radical, in many ways… traditionalist.” Seven years later, in a review of the band’s seminal album The Joshua Tree, Simon Reynolds writes that the band’s very existence is “at once radical and reactionary.” I find this not-conversation of radicality especially amusing considering the band’s current reputation among my generation as that dad-rock group whose 2014 album was forced upon anyone with an iPhone— an idea that would be humorously unfathomable for those critics writing in the 80s.

The Rock’s Backpages archive is the perfect tool to read music journalism from years past, uncolored by retrospection.”

U2 - The Joshua Tree

And here is student assistant Alex’s (class of 2021) take on this resource:

Rock’s Backpages is a fascinating resource and a deep dive into the views on musicians in their prime. If you have ever wondered what mainstream journalists thought of The Beatles in 1963 or AC/DC in 1975, this resource is right for you. You can use the “Free Articles” section on the left side of the screen under the resource’s Library to find an assortment of 1000s of articles on pop and rock stars through the ages. You can also easily search for any article you want to read and filter by artist, genre, publication, or writer. Rock and Pop music took the world by storm in the 20th century and you can read all about it as it happened with this amazing resource.”

AC/DC '75 - Beatles '63