Rubrics

Keyword Response and Reply Comment Rubric

Criteria	Excellent	Good	Poor
Response Post	15 Points Fully addresses reading and illustrates keyword use in contemporary media or experience with example	12 Points Mostly addresses reading, partially illustrates keyword use, or provides unclear example	10 Points Misses some aspect of the assignment, or submitted but incomplete
Reply Comments	10 Points Two meaningful contributions added	7 Points One meaningful contribution added, or both contributions lack excellence	5 Points Reply is unclear, unrelated to original post, or lack meaningful contribution to conversation

Response Paper Rubric

Criteria	Excellent	Good	Average	Poor
Identifies Keywords	25 Points Fully defines & explains keyword and reason for selection	20 Points Mostly defines & explains keyword and reason for selection	15 Points Aspects of definition or explanation missing	10 Points Inadequate or incomplete definition or explanation of keyword
Illustrates Keyword in Media	50 Points Clearly documents how the keyword concepts are engaged through media	40 Points Mostly documents how keyword concepts are engages	30 Points Aspects of documentation are missing or unclear	20 Points Inadequate documentation
Uses Keyword as Lens	25 Points Clearly uses keyword as a critical lens to explain media	20 Points Somewhat clearly uses keywords as critical lenses	15 Points Obscurely or inadequately uses keyword as critical lens	10 Points Poor, surface approach to critical lens
Writes Clearly & Effectively	25 Points Clear, concise prose is used throughout	20 Points Some minor errors in clarity, style, and structure	15 Points Some significant errors in parts of the paper	10 Points Many significant errors throughout

Field Experience Report Rubric

Criteria	Excellent	Good	Average	Poor
Summary	15 Points Provides a complete summary of performance in own words	12 Points Good summary of performance	10 Points Some details missing in summary	8 Points Incomplete, nonexistent summary OR summary far too long and detailed
Keyword	15 Points Clearly identifies keyword concepts or ideas	12 Points Mostly clearly identifies keyword concepts or ideas	10 Points Cursory identification of keyword concepts/ideas	8 Points Missing or unclear keyword identification
Lens	30 Points Thoroughly illustrates how keyword concept or idea engaged	25 Points Largely illustrates how keyword concepts/ideas are engaged	20 Points Partially illustrations how keyword concept or idea engaged	15 Points Incomplete or missing illustrations
Clarity	15 Points Clear, concise, and grammatically correct	12 Points Minor lack of clarity	10 Points Some lack of clarity	8 Points Unclear or significant grammatical or mechanical errors

ArcGIS StoryMap Rubric

Criteria	Excellent	Good	Average	Poor
Keyword	75 Points Identifies and fully builds out a storymap of the selected keyword	60 Points Identifies but lacks complete build out of keyword storymap	45 Points Lacks clarity in identifying and/or building out storymap of the keyword	30 Points Poorly or incompletely connects to keyword concepts or ideas
Accuracy	75 Points Accurately depicts the storymap of the keyword without errors or misinterpretation	60 Points Minor errors in interpretation or errors in presentation of keyword	45 Points More significant errors in presentation of keyword	30 Points Major errors in presentation of keyword
Creativity	25 Points Provides depth and breadth of creativity, integrating multiple complete media types	20 Points Represents a creative approach, but lacks some thoroughness, breadth, or depth of creative integration	15 Points Lacks creativity or breadth and depth of integration of multiple media, but completes media integration	10 Points Incomplete media integration, incomplete depth or breadth; lacks creative approach
StoryMap Quality	25 Points Takes full advantage of StoryMap medium, demonstrating technological and information literacy	20 Points Mostly takes full advantage of StoryMap medium, although some issues may be present	15 Points Incompletely takes advantage of medium, demonstration a minor lack of literacy	10 Points Demonstrates little mastery or literacy