Skip to content

Blog Post for 9/30

In Walt’s article, “The myth of American exceptionalism,” I found it very interesting to see the way we view our country versus the truth based on the idea of American exceptionalism. American exceptionalism is what allows us to believe that our values, political system and history are unique and worthy of universal admiration. Walt tells us that this is in fact, mostly a myth. It is interesting to me that we have such a confident view that we are the greatest and best at everything, which history clearly shows we are not. Not to say we are an awful country – we aren’t, and have definitely accomplished a lot, but we definitely are not as great as we believe. Out of the five myths, the one that stuck out to me most was the fourth: the United States is responsible for most good in the world. Walt says in this section, “Bottom line: Americans take too much credit for global progress and accept too little blame for areas where U.S. policy has in fact been counterproductive.” This quote to me, was the most important line in the article. I feel like it gave the overarching theme of what he was trying to say, because most other myths could fall into this category. For example, myth number 3 says, America’s success is due to its special genius. First of all, Walt explains that it’s not, it sometimes is purely luck. And second, this myth is based on the assumption that they are always successful, which is not true. This then proves Walt’s point about how America doesn’t take credit for anything in history that has been counterproductive.

This plays into Zinn’s chapter, “The empire and the people,” because of how the US went to Cuba only for their own benefit. Zinn discusses that before William McKinley being elected as president, he had said, “we want a foreign marker for our surplus products” (299). Going into Cuba was really only so that America could benefit off of a new market. They didn’t care about their freedom or really helping Cubans rebel at all. Zinn tells us this is what he believes when he says, “American merchants did not need colonies or wars of conquest if they could just have free access to markets” (301). Zinn gives us the name “open door” for the free access to markets. America really only wanted to ensure an open door between them and Cuba, which allowed for better economy. This part of Zinn’s chapter ties back to the myths of American exceptionalism because this is America going in as if they’re doing something helpful for Cuba, when really the intentions were to help themselves.

Published inUncategorized

3 Comments

  1. Julia Borger Julia Borger

    I also saw a connection between Walt’s myths and the motive of the American leaders to take over Cuba. With the Americans’ desire solely to expand their economic power into new markets, they disregard everything else, as they think this reason validates their exploitation. I wonder how different our country would have been if a force counterattacked this motive successfully- would we still be the largest economy in the world?

  2. Alexander Barnett Alexander Barnett

    It’s sad that our leaders feel the need to constantly deceive us as citizens by using motives such as helping the Cubans rebel when in reality they are just using it to cover up their own desire to use Cuba for their own gain.

  3. Carly Cohen Carly Cohen

    The fourth myth stuck out to me as well. America is so quick to take credit for the things in our world that go right or are successful, but shy away super fast from things that don’t go as well. I believe that this definitely ties in to the American Imperialism effect that is so prominent in our country.

Leave a Reply

css.php