Reading response 4/20

I thought that the first short essay was the most compelling. I think that a lot of times, people have good intentions but may not know the best way to direct those intentions. I read a book called Half the Sky for one of my other classes and it said that oftentimes people coming into a community do not know the best ways to help that community. They may assume that sending money will solve the problem when there is something deeper than just an issue of money. I went to one of the entrepreneurship lectures before spring break and the woman who spoke talked about starting a program that reads to children. Not only does this help the children emotionally and intellectually, but it also helped them stay in school. It got them excited about reading and learning which fostered their love for school.

This also reminded me about the doing good better discussion that we had earlier in the semester. It is sometimes hard to figure out what the best way to do good is. It takes work, and you have to actually try and figure out what the community really needs. Throwing money at a problem is not always the best way to fix it. We talked about the seesaw pumps that were a huge failure. People came in and thought they knew how to solve the problem when they were really just creating more problems in the long term. Though people often have good intentions, there is more effort that needs to be put in than just inserting yourself into an issue and assuming you know best.

3 thoughts on “Reading response 4/20

  1. Caitlyn Lindstrom

    I think you bring up a really good point that the issue of debate is whether money is actually effective in contributing to a positive change. It develops the complexity of how to get distribute the resources from those who are well-off to those who are struggling. Money is a highly valued resource in society, but it does not always result in positive change.

  2. Megan Brooks

    I also thought you brought up a good point about the discussion of doing good better. It reminds me of the play pump in Africa and how the best intentions can lead to the worst outcomes.

  3. Megan Geher

    I enjoyed your point about despite people having good intentions, the results of these intentions are not always the best. Too often people insert themselves into scenarios assuming that because their heart is in the right place, their ideas are solid.

Comments are closed.