Blog Post 3/8

I thought the concept of mind bugs was so interesting. I know that what we think we are seeing is not always the truth, but it surprised me how wrong that we can be. The fact that our brains have evolved so much is miraculous, but there are still so many shortcomings. There are real consequences to having our brain trick us into seeing something we are not. This is seen in recalling crimes or dramatic events because our brains jump to conclusions and make pathways that are not there. Depending on how our brains perceive information, two people could possibly convince themselves and recall two very different events. I thought the idea that we could misidentify a suspect or a random person for a criminal was frightening because that is unfair. Our brain adds details that can be damaging because it’s hard to determine where we stray from the exact truth. I thought this was important especially in criminal cases because, when identifying suspects in a lineup, you could have filled in a blank that is incorrect. I also think criminal lineups are unreliable because, as the reading mentioned, word choice really matters when talking about previous events. The fact that jurors can be swayed by the simple addition of one detail is also extremely frightening. I think that, while the criminal justice system in the U.S. is technically functioning, there are a lot of changes to be made to ensure that biases and mindbugs don’t play as big of a role in it (even though I have no clue how that would look or if it’s even possible! My biggest guess is education on biases and stuff like this).

Another thing that I think is really important to include while talking about this subject is biases. Biases can make those jumps in your brain happen even faster which makes it all the more complicated. I have taken a couple implicit bias tests before and they all have been really impactful. Some I was happy to see that there was no implicit bias and then others left me a little disheartened. However, I think the fact that we get to study and understand this is amazing. While implicit biases exist and affect our thinking, the more conscious we are of them and how they work, the easier they will be to dismantle. Like these mindbugs, hopefully we can start to understand what is really there and what is our brain trying to reach conclusions faster. I think it is really incredible that we are so far evolved that we can understand this, so I think it should be standard practices to see where your biases lie and how you can be aware and actively fight against them, even though they will be almost impossible to get rid of. We all need to do our part to make sure we each are treating others fairly and equitably because I think that will make for healthier and happier environments!

2 thoughts on “Blog Post 3/8

  1. Leah Kulma

    Your comments regarding how mind bugs can affect justice systems are really important in the discussion of ethics too. If our minds do fill in the blanks and maybe create details that are not 100% truthful how do we evaluate that ethically? And kind of what you were saying, it isn’t necessarily any one human’s fault for acting as their brain reacts, but to what extent that affects the outcomes of cases or encounters with law enforcement could be really important to understand and dissect.

  2. Michael Kyle

    I think one of the few ways to fight or counteract mindbugs is to increase education and knowledge, which of course is much easier said than done. That’s why you shouldn’t make decisions until you can make an informed one. Unfortunately it’s practically impossible to learn everything and educational resources aren’t available to everyone. As you mentioned it is scary how jurors and judges who are determining the outcome of someone’s life can be swayed by these mindbugs, and I feel that they often (and sometimes legally required to) make a decision, although the don’t have all the details.

Comments are closed.