Struggles with the Archives

Historian, Durba Ghosh, began her research in the British and Indian archives, taking interest in the intimate relationships between British men and Indian women during the early British colonial period in India. In the India Office Library in Calcutta, Ghosh came into conflict with archivists who harbored incompatible viewpoints about the suitability of her topic, and who ultimately had the power to provide her with materials for her project. After her frustrating encounters with the Indian archives, she concluded, “While I was busy reading the archives, I found the archives were busy reading me.” Continue reading

Mechanisms of Power: How National Governments and Archivists Influence the Archives

National archives are widely understood as records of a country’s history, culture, and government activities. Though we hold ideals that these collections will be complete, neutral, and available to anyone who has an interest in them, this is rarely the case. Both national governments, and the archivists employed by them, influence the archives with their own political and cultural agendas, both on purpose and unintentionally. Examples of these occurrences are documented in Archive Stories: Facts, Fictions, and the Writing of History, a recent collection of essays by historians with experience working in national archives from around the world. The “Historians Workshop” course at the University of Richmond studied these “archive stories” alongside two UR historians who visited our class and shared their own experiences: Dr. Manuela Meyer, a historian of Brazil, and Dr. David Brandenberger, a Soviet historian. Their stories raise an important question: In what ways do national governments and archivists affect the neutrality and accessibility of national archives? Continue reading