The first video we needed to review before class connects very well with the graphic organizer we have used/discussed in the first 2 class sessions. Memory shows us what we know (or think) happened in the past while history is what actually happened based on primary sources we have to complete research with today. So for the “It says, I say, and so” organizer, our memory is what we need to use for the “I say” column, History (primary sources) is what we need to use for the “It says” column, and we need to evaluate both pieces of information to determine what our “and so” answer should be.
The main thing I learned in class is that there isn’t necessarily one right answer to any historical question based on the information used to arrive at that answer. Yes, it is one thing if everyone who is answering the same question is reaching their answer by using the same primary sources, then answers, most likely, will be in the same realm as one another. However, some people do tend to pick different parts of the same source to use in creating their answer. The big difference will come into play when a group is told to take a question or topic and come up with what happened using different primary sources.
When people use different sources to come up with one realization of what took place, the answers will be directly reflected by those sources used. What I am getting at is the fact that all sources are not reliable. This was a big takeaway for me in class. Even though, each primary source “is” accurate based on the first hand account of the person or who ever created it, the source may not be valid for the purpose of the research. The information can also be different based on the point of view. It is important to make sure that you have several sources from different places. I believe someone in class said that you should find multiple sources to back up your “I say” and look to find multiple sources that question what you thought. Then you can tell the “whole” history.
I wonder if we were given different primary sources instead of the same primary sources in class, what the different answers would have been with the boycott activity.
Three key points from class:
- History is a slow process – Hands on learning takes time
- Make a lesson/strategy your own – Make changes so it makes sense to you
- Go beyond the textbook – Primary sources are key to learning